So often, I read the super-popular, highly rated book of
the hour and I’m like, “Meh.” Then I
find some book I LOVE, and the 47 reviews are ho-hum, and no one I talk to has ever
heard of it.
[Sigh]
I LOVED this.
Reading as an adult who loves animals (and invented animals) and
light-hearted reads where violence is not the solution, I thoroughly enjoyed
this book. I even made myself ration
it.
So, yeah, maybe some of the characters were a bit one-dimensional,
and maybe I would have liked to know a little more about how all these
creatures fit in (or didn't) in the wider world outside the story, and maybe
the solution was a little too easy…but it was all so delightfully fun and
charming and full of great imaginary creatures and really funny bits that I
just didn’t care about any of its minor issues.
I highly recommend Pip Bartlett's Guide to Magical Creatures. With some series I’m like, “Great.
I have to read MORE?” With this
one I’m like, “Yes!! There’s more!!!!”
[Happy dance].
I rarely give 5
stars to novels. This is probably more
like a 4 or 4.5 for the average reader
who isn’t quite as obsessed with magical animals as I am, but for me: 5 stars, no question.
P.S. As a writer, I'm always curious how the process works when a novel has two authors. Whatever Jackson Pearce and Maggie Stiefvater did, it worked. Full disclosure: I listened to a YA novel by Maggie Stiefvater that I didn't love (Call Down the Hawk). Her talent was apparent, but I didn't particularly enjoy the book. This one, however, has all my stamps of approval.